LinkedIn: technological and financial giants; but morally pygmies

When LinkedIn decided to create a China-hosted version of its website in February, 2014, it made a decision to compromise the company's values in the pursuit of the dollar.

It's important to note that before LinkedIn launched LingYing (the local version of the site), LinkedIn was already active in China. By their own account, they had four million registered users (with little marketing effort), a Chinese-language interface and China-based clients who were buying recruitment ads on the platform (the major source of their revenue). The site had been blocked by the authorities for one 24-hour period but otherwise was always accessible.

So why was it necessary for LinkedIn to create a local entity in China? With a local entity the company would be able to issue official receipts in RMB, making it more convenient for local companies to buy advertising on the site. A local entity also makes it easier to secure marketing deals to promote LingYing in China.

But perhaps the biggest appeal in creating a local entity for LinkedIn is that it would be among the few foreign internet companies who could cosy up with Lu Wei and the Cyberspace Administration of China (CAC). Having that kind of a relationship with CAC surely helps the business and those who are associated with the company.

2015-07-14-1436865048-6462717-1115415785_14326334877831n.jpg

LinkedIn's Reid Hoffman meets China's cyber czar Lu Wei for the umpteenth time.

There are surely other additional benefits, but in order to operate as a local entity, LinkedIn had to agree to the following:

  • To censor content and users on the platform, inside and outside of China, on a 24/7 basis at the behest of the authorities.
  • To store all data about its Chinese users on servers inside China and to agree to allow the Chinese authorities to access this data whenever they want to.
  • To follow all present and future regulations on internet operations in China.

LinkedIn already has egg on its face over its handling of censorship in China. While their commitment to transparency remains vague and noncommittal ("may", "could", "attempt"), the company's CEO, Jeff Weiner, has been more explicit in his description of how he handles censorship. The following is a transcript from the 22 minute mark in an interview with BuzzFeed's Mat Honan:

Weiner: "I'll tell ya, you can have any discussion you want theoretically, but when you are actually asked to censor even one thing, one profile or one update, it's gut-wrenching. It's gut-wrenching. And so we take that very, very seriously.".

Honan: "Do you get involved in those discussions personally?"

Weiner: "So our head of China reports directly to me."

Honan: "Is that a "yes"?

Weiner: "Yeah."

(If you want to listen to the entire China discussion, this starts around the 19 minute mark.)

There is no need to sugarcoat Weiner's disingenuousness in this interview. Anybody remotely familiar with how censorship works in China would be able to tell you that it is near impossible that Weiner personally discusses whether to censor individual updates and profiles on LinkedIn. Nor, for that matter, would his China CEO have the time to do that.

If we want to give Weiner the benefit of the doubt and take his comments at face value, this means that he would have to consider, on a daily basis, all of the censorship directives handed down by the authorities and whether or not they applied to each individual member, plus any requests that have been submitted directly to LinkedIn.

Locally registered internet companies, like LingYing, must censor the information which appears on their sites and employ roughly one censor for every 100,000 users on its platform. In its heyday, Weibo employed 4000 censors in house. With LinkedIn's 9 million members in China, this would mean that Weiner and China CEO Derek Shen are personally handling the work of 90 censors. If true, shareholders should be concerned that the CEO is spending more time dealing with censorship than trying to drive recruitment advertising revenue.

Weiner then goes on to say that the justification for censoring content on a global basis is that the potential exists for content to get "re-circulated" back into China, which may put their "members" in danger. This is an argument that seems to hold weight with many foreign internet firms - that Chinese internet users are not mature enough to understand what is appropriate to post and what is not appropriate to post.

We would posit that perhaps LinkedIn executives are not mature enough to handle China. In the midst of market turmoil, we have seen increased censorship of postsrelated to how the authorities handle this situation. Surely, this is the type of content that business people in China would be sharing on LinkedIn. Is this the type of censorship that Weiner finds "gut-wrenching"? Has he ever said "no" to the censors?

We likely will not be able to verify that information because of LinkedIn's local entity in China. It appears that this entity does not submit information for LinkedIn's transparency report. China is not mentioned in any report, despite a flurry of update and profile deletions around the two most recent Tiananmen anniversaries. While LinkedIn does not seemingly provide statistics on content removal, it does provide member data to governments upon request. However, no such requests from China appear in the report. What is the point of issuing an opaque transparency report?

This may be due to the fact that the Chinese authorities have requested that LinkedIn not share information about their requests - another pitfall of doing business in China. As China works through the details of its cybersecurity law, who knows what new requests lurk around the corner? What we do know is this - whatever the request, LinkedIn will be there to meet it, because relationships matter.

The issue of storing data in China raises many questions. What constitutes a Chinese user for LinkedIn? Presumably, the 4 million Chinese users who had joined before LinkedIn registered a local entity had their data shifted to China. Were they informed of this change?

When considering LinkedIn's transparency policy on content removal, it is also safe to assume that if you claim to be based in China or if you use the Chinese-language interface, regardless of where you may live or what language you speak, your information will be stored in data centers in China.

This is a dangerous development for many of LinkedIn's users, including dissidents, activists, journalists and those working in the non-profit sector. In 2004, Yahooinfamously handed over the emails of a dissident at the request of the Chinese authorities. These emails were later used as justification for sending the dissident to prison for eight years. By the letter of the law, LinkedIn would need to do the same. This information could include a user's location, communications and the profiles of people that are in their networks on LinkedIn, regardless of whether or not those users are based in China.

Sometime in May 2015, LinkedIn deleted my profile on their website. In all honesty, my profile was likely violating several items in the company's user agreement, including the use of a real name ("Charlie Smith" is a pseudonym). But how the company has handled the censorship of my account and the censorship of news which the Chinese authorities have deemed harmful, raises many questions about how foreign internet firms who wish to operate in the China market balance local laws against freedom of speech.

GreatFire has used LinkedIn since 2011. To the company's credit, LinkedIn helped us find contacts that could help with our mission of ending online censorship in China. We then started to automatically post our FreeWeibo Twitter feed to our LinkedIn profile and we expanded our network by connecting to Chinese who were working in media in China. As the LinkedIn site is not blocked, this proved to be an effective means of distributing banned content.

LinkedIn never informed me my account was taken offline. IFTTT, the app I used to auto post from my Twitter feed informed me that the LinkedIn recipe was no longer working. I wrote to LinkedIn twice before I received an answer about my account. The company then asked me to send government issued-ID to prove that the photo I was using on my profile matched my identity (I used a picture of Lu Wei as my profile photo). After I submitted copies of this information (not my real identity) I was then told that my account was being restricted because of "inappropriate content". They furthermore responded:

LinkedIn determined that recent public activity you posted (such as comments, or items shared with your network) contained content prohibited in China.

LinkedIn users in China who are activists, human rights defenders, working for nonprofits, journalists and the many, many others who operate in fields deemed "sensitive" by the authorities (including lawyers), should take the necessary actions to protect their personal security. The mishandling of the deletion of our four-year old account (with thousands of connections), raises several red flags:

  • After submitting my photo identification to LinkedIn for verification, they confirmed that they have deleted this information from their database. But according to Chinese law, this information needs to be retained, even if accounts are deleted.
  • After LinkedIn communicated that I needed to submit identification to get my account restored, they then told me that my account would be deleted because content I shared on the platform was illegal (they refused to elaborate on what content, specifically). Confusingly, if LinkedIn was deleting my account over content issues, why was it necessary for me to send them my personal identification?
  • LinkedIn will not inform you that your account has been removed or that your updates have been deleted. And their non-committal "commitment" to transparency allows them to take these types of actions.
  • If LinkedIn considered my account to be outside of China, then they would likely be able to delete my personal information from their database. But this then shows that they are practicing Chinese censorship on a global basis. If LinkedIn considered my account to be inside China, and they have deleted my personal information from their database, then they are in violation of Chinese law. But because relationships matter, they likely escaped punishment by the authorities.

As China drafts its cybersecurity law, we can thank businesses like LinkedIn for any new, overbearing requirements. LinkedIn have shown that they will do anything for the authorities in return for market access. Now, when a new foreign company wants to enter the China market, the authorities can simply point at LinkedIn and say "these are the minimum requirements you have to meet".

If LinkedIn mimicked their China approach in the West, human rights organizations would be all over them. It is highly likely that the authorities are demanding that LinkedIn hand over sensitive information about dissidents, activists, civil society actors and any other group deemed to be "picking quarrels". By the letter of the law, LinkedIn will have to comply with these requests - but they will simply see this as a "gut-wrenching" cost of doing business and nothing else.

LinkedIn would do well to heed the words of Tom Lantos who, while investigating Yahoo's complicit cooperation with the Chinese authorities, had this to say about American companies operating in China:

Chinese citizens who had the courage to speak their minds on the internet are in a Chinese gulag because Yahoo chose to reveal their identities to the Chinese government. It is beyond comprehension that an American company would play the role of willing accomplice in the Chinese suppression apparatus. My message to these companies today is simple: your abhorrent activities in China are a disgrace. I simply do not understand how your corporate leadership sleeps at night.

These enterprises, which have grown so powerful, so wealthy, so full of themselves, apparently have very little social conscience, apparently they don't appreciate their success is a result of a free and open and democratic society. What I am suggesting is that they do something in addition, merely, to doing business according to the laws of a repressive regime.

Comments

More Blog Posts

Subscribe to our mailing list
Show content from Blog | Google+ | Twitter | All. Subscribe to our blog using RSS.

Tue, May 23, 2017

Is China establishing cyber sovereignty in the United States?

Last week Twitter came under attack from a DDoS attack orchestrated by the Chinese authorities. While such attacks are not uncommon for websites like Twitter, this one proved unusual. While the Chinese authorities use the Great Firewall to block harmful content from reaching its citizens, it now uses DDoS attacks to take down content that appears on websites beyond its borders. For the Chinese authorities, it is not simply good enough to “protect” the interests of Chinese citizens at home - in their view of cyber sovereignty, any content that might harm China’s interests must be removed, regardless of where the website is located.

And so last week the Chinese authorities determined that Twitter was the target. In particular, the authorities targeted the Twitter account for Guo Wengui (https://twitter.com/KwokMiles), the rebel billionaire who is slowly leaking information about corrupt Chinese government officials via his Twitter account and through his YouTube videos. Guo appeared to ramp up his whistle-blowing efforts last week and the Chinese authorities, in turn, ramped up theirs.

via https://twitter.com/KwokMiles/status/863689935798374401

Mon, Dec 12, 2016

China is the obstacle to Google’s plan to end internet censorship

It’s been three years since Eric Schmidt proclaimed that Google would chart a course to ending online censorship within ten years. Now is a great time to check on Google’s progress, reassess the landscape, benchmark Google’s efforts against others who share the same goal, postulate on the China strategy and offer suggestions on how they might effectively move forward.

flowers on google china plaque

Flowers left outside Google China’s headquarters after its announcement it might leave the country in 2010. Photo: Wikicommons.

What has Google accomplished since November 2013?

The first thing they have accomplished is an entire rebranding of both Google (now Alphabet) and Google Ideas (now Jigsaw). Throughout this blog post, reference is made to both new and old company names.

Google has started to develop two main tools which they believe can help in the fight against censorship. Jigsaw’s DDoS protection service, Project Shield, is effectively preventing censorship-inspired DDoS attacks and recently helped to repel an attack on Brian Krebs’ blog. The service is similar to other anti-DDoS services developed by internet freedom champions and for-profit services like Cloudflare.

Thu, Nov 24, 2016

Facebook: Please, not like this

Facebook is considering launching a censorship tool that would enable the world’s biggest social network to “enter” the China market. Sadly, nobody will be surprised by anything that Mark Zuckerberg decides to do in order to enter the China market. With such low expectations, Facebook is poised to usurp Apple as China’s favorite foreign intelligence gathering partner. If the company launches in China using this strategy they will also successfully erase any bargaining power that other media organizations may hold with the Chinese authorities.

Tue, Jul 05, 2016

GreatFire.org now testing VPN speed and stability in China

There is a commonly held belief in China that if you have a VPN that works then you should keep quiet about it. In terms of freedom of access to information, the problem with this approach is that access to knowledge suddenly is a secret. Today we are launching a project that we hope will destroy that model.

Our newest website, Circumvention Central (CC), aims to provide real-time information and data about circumvention solutions that work in China. Since 2011, we have been collecting data about blocked websites in China and now we will add data about the effectiveness of VPNs and other circumvention tools.

We are launching CC with four main objectives in mind.

Our first objective is to help to grow the number of Chinese who circumvent censorship restrictions in China. By sharing our information and data about these tools, we hope to show a wider audience which circumvention tools are working.

Our second objective is to improve the circumvention experience for users in China by bringing transparency to tool performance. We will measure these tools on speed (how quickly popular websites are loaded) and on stability (the extent to which popular websites load successfully).

Sat, May 07, 2016

The New York Times vs. The Chinese Authorities

Could the New York Times be setting the best path forward for news organizations in China?
Subscribe to our blog using RSS.

Comments

Great blog! Exceptional send with a fully designed jointly with beneficial making This unique excellent write-up shows the great comprehending you have using this style. Appreciate it this original perform the job.
http://american-writers.org/

Great blog! Exceptional send with a fully designed jointly with beneficial making This unique excellent write-up shows the great comprehending you have using this style. Appreciate it this original perform the job.
http://american-writers.org/

Hi, guys, I've released free tool for generating topics for essays. Can you test it?

Hi, guys, I've released free tool for generating topics for essays. Can you test it? http://essaytopicgenerator.com/

Great share...you might also like my content..

Tamasha Box Office Collection

Grt share mate..I loved your content...
Tamasha

Thanks for post this helpful post - Please visit for More information about -
Packers and Movers Hyderabad @
http://www.expert5th.in/packers-and-movers-hyderabad/
Packers and Movers Mumbai @
http://www.expert5th.in/packers-and-movers-mumbai/
Packers and Movers Chennai @
http://www.expert5th.in/packers-and-movers-chennai/

This article is really fantastic and thanks for sharing the valuable post.
Packers and Movers Bangalore @
http://www.expert5th.in/packers-and-movers-bangalore/
Packers and Movers Pune @
http://www.expert5th.in/packers-and-movers-pune/
Packers and Movers Delhi @
http://www.expert5th.in/packers-and-movers-delhi/
Packers and Movers Gurgaon @
http://www.expert5th.in/packers-and-movers-gurgaon/

这些企业,已变得如此强壮,如此富有,如此自大,却很少有社会良知,显然他们并没有认识到他们的成功是因为一个自由和开放的民主社会的结果。-------baidu,qq等国内企业可以理直气壮的反对这句话.

这些企业,已变得如此强壮,如此富有,如此自大,却很少有社会良知,显然他们并没有认识到他们的成功是因为一个自由和开放的民主社会的结果。-------baidu,qq等国内企业可以理直气壮的反对这句话.

Best And Afforadable Shifting Service Providers in all Over India

Top 3 Packers India  @ http://3rd.in/

Packers Movers Bhopal  @ http://packersmoversbhopal.in/

Packers Movers Lucknow @ http://lucknowpackersandmovers.in/

Packers Movers Bhubaneswar @ http://bhubaneswarpackersmovers.in/

Packers Movers Bengaluru  @ http://packers-and-movers-bangalore.in/

Packers Movers Bangalore  @ http://packersmoversbangalore.in

Packers Movers haridwar  @ http://packersmoversharidwar.in/

Packers Movers Chennai  @ http://packersmoverschennai.in/

Packers Movers Delhi  @ http://packers-and-movers-delhi.in/

Packers Movers Jaipur  @ http://jaipurpackersandmovers.in/

Packers Movers Chandigarh  @ http://chandigarhpackersandmovers.in/

Packers Movers Ahmedabad  @ http://packersmoversahmedabad.co.in/

Packers Movers Patna  @ http://packersmoverspatna.in/

Packers Movers  Kolkata  @ http://kolkatapackersmovers.in/

Packers Movers Pune  @ http://packersmoverspune.org/

Packers Movers Hyderabad  @ http://packersmovershyderabadcity.in/

Packers Movers Mumbai  @ http://packersmoversmumbaicity.in/

Packers Movers Gurgaon  @ http://packers-and-movers-gurgaon.in/

Packers Movers Pune  @ http://thebusinessplace.in/

I really like it when folks get together and share ideas.
Great site, stick with it!

Stop by my homepage; Indian Super League live streaming

Howdy! I could have sworn I've been to this site before but after browsing through many of
the articles I realized it's new to me. Anyhow, I'm certainly pleased I came
across it and I'll be book-marking it and
checking back often!

My web site :: פצועים בראש עונה 2 לצפייה ישירה

With best compliments from Packers and Movers
https://www.makingmove.com/

Golden Globe Awards 2016 Live Stream || @ On January 10, 2016 set the date for the 73rd Annual Golden Globe Awards by The Hollywood Foreign Press.

http://goldenglobeawards2016livestream.com/

Justin Bieber Tickets Tours & Concert Updates
http://justinbieberconcert.co/

Knock! Knock! Knock!!! Hello……!!!! We are back with a big bang award show which is Golden Globe Award 2016. Great show, some great people, beautiful and spectacularly talented actresses/actors and lots of fun, entertainment, and suspense’re to be revealed.

This award has been continuing since 1943. Group of writers gathered together to frame the Hollywood Foreign Press Association and made liberally distributed award named Golden globe Award where they play momentous role in film making. The first award was being honored on best achievement in 1943 filmmaking and was held in January 1944, at the 20th Century –Fox studios. Successively, every year ceremonies were held in different venues for decades.

Get More Details visit websites:
Packers and Movers in Jaipur
http://www.shiftingsolutions.in/packers-and-movers-jaipur.html
Packers and Movers in Chennai
http://www.shiftingsolutions.in/packers-and-movers-chennai.html

Varanasi Packers and movers and near city allahabad lucknow can hire sadym in affordable price
http://www.saydm.com/packers-and-movers-varanasi
Packers movers lucknow @ http://www.saydm.com/packers-and-movers-lucknow

Hey what a brilliant post I have come across and believe me I have been searching out for this similar kind of post for past a week and hardly came across this. Thank you very much and will look for more postings from you.
[url=http://geometrydash.co]geometry dash[/url]

Very interesting blog. Alot of blogs I see these days don't really provide anything that I'm interested in, but I'm most definately interested in this one. Just thought that I would post and let you know.
geometry dash

Very informative piece of writing! Great website! The content of the articles are relevant and up-to-date!

I am so glad to have a chance to read your wonderful article. I am looking forward to read more of your works and posts. http://www.essayscampus.com/

This is really great work. Thank you for sharing such a useful information here in the blog.
Audit Assignment Help

These kind essay write of articles are always attractive and I am happy to find so many good point here in the post, writing is simply great, thanks for sharing.

Packers and Movers in Pune @ http://www.5th.co.in/packers-and-movers-pune/
Packers and Movers in Gurgaon @ http://www.5th.co.in/packers-and-movers-gurgaon/
Packers and Movers in Bangalore @ http://www.5th.co.in/packers-and-movers-bangalore/
Packers and Movers in Noida @ http://www.5th.co.in/packers-and-movers-noida/
Packers and Movers in Navi Mumbai @ http://www.5th.co.in/packers-and-movers-navi-mumbai/
Packers and Movers in Thane @ http://www.5th.co.in/packers-and-movers-thane/

deliver rakhi in delhi
SEND RAKHI TO DELHI
http://www.sendeliterakhitoindia.com/send-rakhi-to-delhi.php

Pages

Add new comment

Filtered HTML

  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <blockquote> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.